Updated April 26, 2023, 11:42 a.m. ET
New York Post may be compensated and/or receive an affiliate commission if you click or buy through our links. Featured pricing is subject to change.
Mother’s Day just hits different when you become a mom. It only happens once after all, which makes the first Mother’s Day a big deal — especially after all the hard work she went through to bring her bundle of joy into the world. Finding the best first Mother’s Day gift will commemorate this milestone in her life, while celebrating her new title as a mom.
No matter if she’s anxiously counting down the days until she meets her little one or is celebrating the first time they roll onto their stomach, it’s important to surprise her with an extra-special gift to acknowledge how amazing she is.
Thankfully, there are no limits to what you can gift her. Go the practical route with a playpen for babies, stylish diaper bag or even baby lotion, which will earn you a much-appreciated thank you. Or, pamper the first-time mom with some self-care tools to remind her to take some time for herself such as a relaxing bath bomb, smoothing eye cream or soothing face mask.
To help ensure you come with a stellar gift, we’ve put together a list of the best first Mother’s Day gift ideas she’ll be crying tears of joy over. Check below to find the most unique and thoughtful gifts that’ll make her first Mother’s Day an unforgettable one.
1. Dikaslon Diaper Bag Backpack, $43 to $48
Carrying diapers, toys, extra clothes and more can be done in style with the help of this sleek backpack. Not only does it feature many (and we do mean many) pockets, but it even comes with a portable changing mat to making diaper changes a breeze.
2. ever eden Baby Deluxe Gift Set, $117
Ever eden has the baby-safe skin care set the new mom in your life will be praising you for. It features the National Eczema Organization’s seal of acceptance, while including a range of bath time essentials like face cream, body wash, body lotion, massage oil and diaper rash cream to keep her child’s skin soft and soothed.
3. Hatch The Luxe Nursing Tee, $88
For the nursing moms out there the Hatch Luxe Nursing Tee is a must-have. It’s designed with a convenient top panel to make nursing or pumping totally effortless — without sacrificing style. After receiving this don’t be surprised when she goes back and snags it in the other two shades.
4. Honest Mama Beyond The Bump Kit, $56, original price: $63
Encourage the mom-to-be or first-time mom to take some time for herself with this Honest Beyond The Bump Kit, which features body lotion, body oil, soaking salts and nip balm. The entire kit will upgrade her beauty routine through hydrating and nourishing her skin.
5. Etsy Mother’s Day Socks, $20 to $26
These socks are anything but basic — especially since you can add up to six photos of her precious bundle of joy to be printed alongside the message “best mama ever.”
6. Bubzi Co Baby Handprint and Footprint Maker Kit, $23
They’re only babies once and what better way to memorialize those precious moments than with treasurable keepsake they can look back at forever. Within the frame she can place two baby or family pictures, while the other side showcases her child’s tiny foot and handprint.
7. Becta Design New Mom Gift Basket, $35
What’s wonderful about gift baskets is they come with a mix of goodies the recipient can enjoy. This new mom-themed one contains a “One Line a Day” book for recording memories, two bath bombs to give her an in-house spa treatment, a pair of fluffy socks to kick her feet up in, a muslin blanket to snuggle with her bundle of joy in and more.
8. Biossance Rapid Radiance Set, $35
Having a baby doesn’t leave a lot of time for herself, which is why some skincare treatments can help her feel good while keeping her skin healthy. Biossance’s Rapid Radience Set will have her skin thanking you for its vitamin C oil, eye cream, moisturizer and night serum that’ll leave it brighter, hydrated and, most importantly refreshed.
9. Birthdate Custom Pendant, $149, original price: $199
Becoming a mom is a pretty big deal and what better way to commemorate that than a symbolic necklace or her baby’s birthdate. Simply put in the month, day and year of her child’s birthday and a customized necklace will be created with gorgeous gemstones — including their birthstone.
10. Etsy Custom Mother’s Day Frame, $28 to $90
Rather than go for the classic photo in a frame, upgrade it to this meaningful version that will turn any poem or message into a piece of artwork. Just choose your photo and message then watch as it’s transformed into a photo that’ll certainly have the mom in your life reaching for a tissue.
11. Little Sleepies Rust Rainbows Sleep Shirt, $56
Ramp up the cuteness with a set of matching pajamas that’ll have both her and her child feeling cozy together. For the mom in your life, she can sport this rainbow sleep shirt featuring a button down design, while her baby can wear the matching onesie ($34) resulting in an Instagram-worthy moment.
12. Beary Tidy 5 Piece Diaper Bag Organizer Pouch Set, $39
Diaper bags can quickly turn into a black hole, which causes new moms and their partners to spend an unnecessary amount of time digging around. These organizers will completely eliminate that, and since they’re clear, they’ll avoid thinking “Was it this one I put the pacifier in?”
13. Olaplex Hair Perfector No 3 Repairing Treatment, $30
Your body goes through a lot of changes during and after pregnancy, so give her strands a royal treatment. Olaplex has mastered a repairing formula that will help hydrate dry, brittle hair and only requires application up to twice a week.
14. 7AM Enfant Stroller Warmmuffs, $45
Chilly early morning walks won’t be the same once she slips these onto her stroller. The thick padded gloves feature a wind- and waterproof material that will insulate heat, keeping her hands warm and cozy as she spends time with her bundle of joy.
15. Boba Wrap Baby Carrier, $40, original price: $50
Keep her hands free and baby close by with Boba’s Wrap Baby Carrier. It provides that close skin-to-skin contact without requiring new moms to hold their child in their arms. The unique wrap design is secure and can be tied around comfortably to meet her and her child’s needs.
16. OXO TOT Space Saving Drying Rack, $26
With a new baby also comes a collection of bottles, pacifiers and many attachments, which can take up counter real estate — especially for those living in small spaces. Clear clutter with this space-saving drying rack by OXO, which will allow those baby supplies to air dry without having to stack dishes in a pyramid.
17. Hello Bello Diapers and Wipes Bundle, $70
When in doubt diapers make a great first-time mom gift, and this subscription will ensure she’s stocked up with diapers and wipes. What’s even better is the materials used are chemical and toxin-free, making sure her baby has the best.
18. NutriBullet NBY-50100 Baby Food-Making System, $56, original price: $70
It’s undeniable how cute this blender and its accessories are. Plus, if the new mom you know loves to cook and wants to make fresh baby food, the bundle includes food storage containers for an effortless process.
19. Glossier Mask Duos, $42, original price: $48
She won’t be able to mask her excitement after opening these nutrient-packed face masks. Treat her to some self care with a moisturizing and mega green duo that’ll detoxify and hydrate her skin as she kicks back and relaxes during her child’s afternoon nap.
20. KeaBabies First 5 Years Baby Memory Book Journal, $20
It’s true what they say, kids grow up fast but with this memory book, she’ll be able to relive the first five years whenever she’s feeling nostalgic. Inside there are prompts to fill out and places to store little keepsakes such as the hospital tag from her baby’s birth.
21. BRONAX Cloud Slippers, $20, original price: $36
Even her feet deserve some love — especially with how much she’s on them running to check on her baby and provide them with everything they need. These cloud slippers are as comfy as the name suggest, supporting her feet in comfort while she spends time with her child.
22. Hopebig Portable Bottle Warmer, $56, original price: $69
No matter where she goes she can count on this bottle warmer to heat formula or milk to the perfect temperature every time. All she has to do is power it on, set the temperature and watch as it warms the beverage in seconds. It even includes four different attachments to ensure a single drop isn’t spilt.
23. Munchkin Milkmakers Lactation Cookie Bites, $23
Not only is this a tasty snack for her to munch on, but the ingredients include oats, brewer’s yeast and flax seed — all of which help support lactation for an easier breast pumping and feeding experience.
24. Bearby Cotton Napper, $199
Even moms deserve some nap time, so why not give her a luxe experience with this cozy knitted, weighted blanket. It’ll swaddle her in total comfort and look aesthetically pleasing when not in use.
25. LATME Ice Roller, $10
Ice rollers are not only help with blood circulation but will wake up first-time mom’s skin, helping them feel alert and ready to take on the day — even if they’re only running on four hours of sleep. All she has to do is put it in the freezer and take it out when she’s ready to use, then just gently roll it onto the skin for the best results.
26. Brooklinen Mulberry Silk Eye Mask, $25, original price: $29
For those rare moment’s first-time moms can catch some shut eye, upgrade their sleeping experience with a luxurious silk sleep mask. It’s soft, temperature regulating and will block out any distracting light allowing them to catch some extra Z’s.
27. Regalo My Portable Play Yard, $49 to $60
Make play time less stressful with a portable playpen that allows them to keep a watchful eye and get some household tasks done. Featuring a foldable design, it’s easy to take with you to the backyard or kitchen, while the nylon material means it’s soft yet durable enough to handle rough play.
Rylee Johnston 
Leave a comment